Posted: March 21st, 2023

3 Best History Analysis Essay Questions: How did English-Indian relations evolve during the sixteenth, seventeenth, and eighteenth centuries?

Question 1: How did English-Indian relations evolve during the sixteenth, seventeenth, and eighteenth
centuries?

Question 2: How did African & African American slavery evolve during the seventeenth and eighteenth
centuries?

Question 3: What short- and long-term developments explain why the colonists rebelled against British
authority in 1775?

Ans:

Name

Course

Instructor’s name

Date

How did English-Indian relations evolve during the sixteenth, seventeenth, and eighteenth centuries?

The English and Indian ties were fraught with difficulty and flux in the 1600s, 1700s, and 1800s. The causes that have influenced these relationships over time are the theme of this discussion. The colonial period’s changing economic and political landscape resulted in a relationship between the English and Indian nations distinguished by conflict, cooperation, and competitiveness.

At first, the English saw the Native Americans as pleasant and helpful locals. The colonists gladly participated in trade with the indigenous people who frequented their communities. They prayed that regular interaction with the natives would eventually convert them to Christianity. Native Americans were opposed to and fought against colonial attempts at cultural assimilation.

Because of their stubbornness in not adopting European ways of life, tensions quickly erupted between the two communities. English perspectives of people of other races shifted due to the violence of their encounters with Native Americans. The failure to fully incorporate Native Americans into English society led to the colonial power’s widespread stereotyping of persons of color.

Relationships between the English and Indians were based on commercial exchange in the sixteenth, seventeenth, and eighteenth centuries. The English monopolized trade with Native Americans, allowing them to fix prices for Indian goods and cut out local merchants and kings from the profitable industry.

As a result, smuggling and underground marketplaces sprung up as Indian merchants looked for alternative routes to the market beyond the English monopoly. Due to the English monopoly on commerce with Native Americans, the Native American economy was highly volatile because of the volatility of the prices of their goods in European markets. The book The American Yawp says:

“The English East India Company, chartered in 1600, became the dominant European power in India, with a network of forts and trading posts along the coasts and rivers” (pg. 67)

In the sixteenth century, contact between the English and Indians began, and it was distinguished at first by curiosity, trade, and even bloodshed. In the 1560s, English merchants like John Hawkins started making trips to India in search of spices and textiles to bring back to Europe.

A mutual fascination and admiration distinguished these earliest encounters, with the Indians marveling at English firearms and the Brits taking an interest in Indian art and culture. Yet, conflicts arose when English merchants established a foothold in the Indian market. Established in 1600, the English spread across Indians, intending to gain economic and political sway. As a result, tensions between the English and Indian nations escalated.

As the sixteenth century progressed into the seventeenth, tensions between the English and Indians only increased, as Joseph Locke and Ben Wright expressed in The American Yawp. They say:

“The English and Indian societies remained deeply divided, and English attempts to impose their values and institutions on Indian society were met with resistance and rebellion” (pg. 120).

Starting in the early 1600s, the English company worked on cornering the Indian market, eventually driving out all other European merchants and establishing an effective monopoly on exporting Indian products to Europe. Indian business people and political leaders grew resentful of the English because they were seen as exploitative and imperialist.

Simultaneously, the English expanded their geographical holdings in India by creating fortified trading posts and forming relationships with local kings. Violence and casualties were commonplace during this period of English development, as the colonizers strove to prove their superiority over their Indigenous adversaries and secure their hold on the region’s wealthiest lands and mineral deposits.

English-Indian relations had become even more complex and multifaceted by the eighteenth century. The English East India Company had established itself as a significant political and economic force among the Native Americans, controlling vast territories and resources and exercising significant political influence over Indian rulers. This led to growing resentment among Indians, who saw the English as arrogant and oppressive. As mentioned by Locke and Wright

“As the colonies grew and pushed farther westward, conflicts with native peoples became more frequent and intense” (pg. 74).

At the same time, however, the English began to adopt more conciliatory policies towards Indian rulers, seeking stability and avoiding open conflict. This led to the development of a complex system of alliances and treaties between English and Indian rulers, as both sides sought to maintain their interests while avoiding open conflict.

Another critical factor in the evolution of English-Indian relations was religion. The English were Protestant Christians, while most Indians were Hindu or Muslim. This led to cultural clashes and misunderstandings as the English sought to spread their religion and cultural values among the Native Americans.

The English saw themselves as superior to the “heathen” Indians and sought to “civilize” them by spreading Christianity and European cultural values. This led to the development of missionary activities, often met with suspicion and hostility by Indian rulers and religious leaders. The American Yawp authors say, “missionaries spread Christianity to the Indian tribes of the Plains and the West, but their efforts were met with mixed success” (pg. 214).

Furthermore, the English Company’s expansion into Native American territories led to the displacement and marginalization of local communities. The English sought to establish dominance over Native American rivals by seizing control of valuable resources, such as land and minerals. This often led to violent clashes with local communities, who saw the English as invaders and oppressors.

The English colonizers also introduced a system of indentured labor, which involved the forced labor of Native American workers on English plantations and factories. According to The American Yawp, “Indians were forced to perform hard labor …, where many suffered and died” (pg. 16). This system was marked by great brutality and exploitation, leading to growing resentment and resistance among Indian workers.

Another significant development in English-Indian relations was the emergence of Indian nationalism and anti-colonialism in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. The Indian National Congress, founded in 1885, sought to unite Indians against British rule and promote the cause of Indian self-rule. This movement was led by figures such as Mohandas Gandhi, who advocated nonviolent resistance to the British government and sought to unite Indians of all religious and ethnic backgrounds.

The expansion of English colonies and the encroachment on Indian land by the English soured relations between the two countries in the seventeenth century.

“The English expanded their territorial holdings in India in the eighteenth century, gradually taking over more of the subcontinent through a combination of alliances with local rulers, military conquests, and political maneuvering” (pg. 119).

To eliminate what they saw as Native roadblocks to their progress, the Brits regularly resorted to war and other violent means. To protect their autonomy, the Indians fought off English colonization. Yet, the scales of justice were tipped strongly in favor of the English, and many Native nations were wiped out by conflict, sickness, and forced migration.

As the English formed a series of treaties with Indian tribes in the eighteenth century, the nature of Anglo-Indian interactions grew increasingly complicated. The treaty aimed to ensure peaceful cohabitation between the English and the Indians. Still, they generally favored the English and put the Indians in a weaker position.

Nonetheless, Indians pushed back against English colonization and claimed independence, which sparked several significant conflicts where “King Philip’s War erupted” (pg. 83) from 1675 to 1766. When the eighteenth century came to a close, the English had conquered or colonized most Indian nations, and relations between the two were defined by dominance and servitude on both sides.

In conclusion, English-Indian relations exhibited complexity and nuance throughout the 1600s, 1700s, and 1800s. The establishment of Indian nationalism, anti-colonialism, and trade and religious development characterized these ties.

Conflicts arose when Native American merchants and rulers became increasingly shutting out of the profitable trade in Indian products. Due to the English company’s monopoly over commerce, the prices of Indian commodities were highly volatile.

Conflicts arose when the Brits tried to impose their religion and cultural norms on Native Americans. Relationships between the English and Indians were already tense due to the cruel indentured labor system and the forced relocation and marginalization of indigenous people.

Throughout the latter half of the 18th century, the English took a more amicable stance towards Indian kings in an effort to preserve peace and prevent war. As both sides adapted to the colonial era’s shifting political and economic climate, the relationship between the English and Indian nations was ultimately distinguished by competition, cooperation, and conflict.